Overall great house and we enjoyed it. There were some

August 17, 2025

Overall great house and we enjoyed it. There were some home maintenance issues (cracked plexi glass in window) and a few mouse droppings found in the kitchen. Nothing major though.

Stayed at: Bluebird Cabin

We had a wonderful stay! The house was great and

August 16, 2025

We had a wonderful stay! The house was great and had everything we needed for a great visit. Check-in was smooth and straightforward, and check-out couldn’t have been easier. Overall, an excellent experience—we’d definitely stay again!

Stayed at: Hidden Ridge

August 14, 2025

Stayed at: Little River

Our stay was great! A few recommendations to make the

August 13, 2025

Our stay was great! A few recommendations to make the place awesome: - the access to the water is very treacherous (steep and muddy even though it hadn’t rained in days). It would be impossible to safely carry down the canoe. To let guests have better access to this I would recommend putting in gravel/rocks or wood steps into the hill. - wine glasses!! We couldn’t find any in the home. - the remote for the tv was dead. I think it’s solar powered but it wasn’t working even after putting in sun - a screen door to the porch would be amazing. We wanted to keep bugs out and the glass door is soooo heavy to open and close all the time - we weren’t able to get the tiki torches to light for the bug repellant - may have been user error though. Otherwise we had a wonderful stay!!

Stayed at: Riverside Cabin (Cabin only)

Fantastic location. Could not have been better. Needed some help

August 13, 2025

Fantastic location. Could not have been better. Needed some help with a minor issue at the house and the customer service team was excellent.

Stayed at: Whimsy Woods

A very impressive property.

August 13, 2025

A very impressive property.

Stayed at: West Kill Farmhouse

August 13, 2025

Stayed at: Olive Pit

This was our second Red Cottage rental and they continue

August 12, 2025

This was our second Red Cottage rental and they continue to impress us! This house was so well equipped (the kitchen had everything) and was perfect for our extended family vacation with young kids. We would absolutely stay here again!

Stayed at: Myers Ridge

Beautiful, clean, modern, functional house! We loved the nearby lake,

August 12, 2025

Beautiful, clean, modern, functional house! We loved the nearby lake, sitting on the porch, and excursions into town.

Stayed at: Clancy House

August 12, 2025

Stayed at: Bear Hollow

My family and I had a great time at the

August 11, 2025

My family and I had a great time at the library retreat in Pine Plains! The property was gorgeous and great for our large family. There were a few things that could be improved -- there were several wasps nests around the property and a few of us got stung! The rental team was very responsive and someone came out the next day to spray them. We also noticed there were some bats living in one of the chimneys! Luckily they didn't get into the house, but it was a bit unsettling. The listing also stated there were 4 queen sized beds and 2 doubles, but we found out there were actually 3 queen sized beds and 3 double sized beds, which was difficult with the number of and height of our fam! Accurate information in that regard is appreciated. Another suggestion is to install curtains/blinds to all the bedrooms. Some bedrooms did not have any kind of coverings. We also wished there was more outdoor furniture to enjoy. The scenery was beautiful but there were no tables or chairs on the patios. Otherwise the houses were all beautifully decorated and maintained. The rental team was very responsive to any questions we had, which was great. Overall it was a great family vacation spot!

Stayed at: The Library Retreat

We had a great time — the house was beautiful

August 11, 2025

We had a great time -- the house was beautiful and very functional.

Stayed at: Casa Manzara

All Reviews

Perfectly curated homes for groups of 12 or more

Kaaterskill Mountain House

Taghkanic House

Graybarn at Copake Lake

Lotus Lodge

Fernbrook

Crossbridge – Full Property (House + Apartment)

Doodletown Lodge & Cabin

Doodletown Lodge

Abbey Road Farmhouse

The Library Retreat

Sunflower Farmhouse

Olive Pit

Clementine Creekhouse

The Gables

The Homestead

The Homestead (House only)

Overall great house and we enjoyed it. There were some

We had a wonderful stay! The house was great and

Our stay was great! A few recommendations to make the

Fantastic location. Could not have been better. Needed some help

A very impressive property.

This was our second Red Cottage rental and they continue

Beautiful, clean, modern, functional house! We loved the nearby lake,

My family and I had a great time at the

We had a great time — the house was beautiful

Overall great house and we enjoyed it. There were some

We had a wonderful stay! The house was great and

Our stay was great! A few recommendations to make the

Fantastic location. Could not have been better. Needed some help

A very impressive property.

This was our second Red Cottage rental and they continue

Beautiful, clean, modern, functional house! We loved the nearby lake,

My family and I had a great time at the

We had a great time — the house was beautiful