Guide to a Great Slice in the HV & Catskills
The Hudson Valley and Catskills are a slice of upstate heaven and we mean that literally. With wood-fired pies, brick oven classics, and creative toppings that go way beyond pepperoni, this region is a dream for pizza lovers. From riverside towns to mountain hamlets, you’ll find crusts that crackle, cheese that stretches, and flavors that surprise. Whether you’re after a casual slice or a destination-worthy meal, here’s our guide to the best pizza spots across the Hudson Valley and Catskills.
1. LOLA Pizza
📍Location: 243 Fair St, Kingston, NY
LOLA Pizza has mastered the balance between nostalgic comfort and upscale flair. With its golden crust, tangy tomato sauce, and clever topping combos, every pie feels like a small event. Add in good lighting and a buzzy crowd, it’s an easy win.
2. Hudson & Packard
📍Location: 29 Academy St, Poughkeepsie, NY
Hudson & Packard is where Detroit-style pizza shines. Their thick, cheesy, crispy-edged squares come loaded with creative toppings and big flavor. It’s a casual, cool spot that locals are fiercely loyal to for good reason.
3. Cosimo’s Brick Oven
📍Location: 620 NY-211 E, Middletown, NY
Cosimo’s Brick Oven brings a polished take on classic Italian pies. The crusts are thin and bubbly, the toppings are high-quality, and there’s always something new on the seasonal menu. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, it’s a solid go-to for crowd-pleasing pizza.
4. Lolita’s Pizza
📍Location: 129 Washington St, Poughkeepsie, NY
Lolita’s Pizza turns out airy sourdough pies from a wood-fired oven just steps from the Hudson River. Their creative toppings and local ingredients give each pizza its own personality. Sit at the bar for a front-row seat to the action or take it to-go and find a riverfront bench.
5. The Half Moon
📍Location: 48 S Front St, Hudson, NY
At The Half Moon, you’ll find New York-style slices that are as unfussy as they are delicious. It’s part dive bar, part pizza joint, and 100% local hangout. Come late, grab a slice, and enjoy the no-frills charm that Hudson locals love.
6. The Katskeller
📍Location: 33 Pearl St, Livingston Manor, NY
The Katskeller offers wood-fired pizza in a cozy space that feels like a Catskills lodge with a modern twist. With rotating pies, craft beer, and a laid-back vibe, it’s the perfect post-hike reward or weekend dinner destination. Bonus: there’s plenty of room for the whole crew.
7. The Laundrette
📍Location: 20 5th St, Narrowsburg, NY
The Laundrette is part riverside café, part pizza paradise, and 100% worth the trip. Their wood-fired pies are made with long-fermented dough and seasonal ingredients that always hit the mark. Stay for a spritz, snag a patio seat, and let the afternoon roll on.
8. Enoteca Ama
📍Location: 328 Main St, Beacon, NY
Enoteca Ama brings rustic Italian charm to Beacon with perfectly blistered crusts and simple, elegant toppings. The space is small and intimate, which makes it ideal for a slow evening with wine and good conversation. Every bite feels intentional.
9. Westwind Orchard
📍Location: 215 Lower Whitfield Rd, Accord, NY
Westwind Orchard pairs their house-made cider with some of the most craveable pizza in the Catskills. Wood-fired and topped with local produce, the pies feel rustic in the best way. It’s a slice-and-sip setup that’s tough to beat on a sunny afternoon.
10. Forage Pizza
📍Location: 97 Center St, Forestburgh, NY
Forage Pizza keeps it small-batch, slow-fermented, and endlessly flavorful. Their pies are crisp on the bottom, light on the crust, and heavy on freshness. The vibe is laid-back, with just enough edge to feel special.
11. Woodhouse Pizza
📍Location: 11134 NY-32, Greenville, NY
Woodhouse Pizza makes sourdough magic in a sleek, modern space with big community energy. Their topping game is strong, think seasonal veggies, locally cured meats, and inventive sauces. Pair it with a local beer and hang for a while.
12. Beekman Ale House
📍Location: 92 Beekman Ave, Sleepy Hollow, NY
Beekman Ale House blends elevated bar food with a serious love for pizza. The crust is crackly, the cheese is gooey, and the whole menu is built to satisfy. Grab a pint and a booth and settle in. This is where comfort food comes to life.
13. Ollie’s Pizza
📍Location: 5501 NY-213, High Falls, NY
Ollie’s Pizza has that wood-fired magic you can smell from the parking lot. Their naturally leavened dough gets just the right char, and the seasonal toppings are straight from local farms. On warm nights, the backyard tables are the place to be.
14. Pizzeria Posto
📍Location: 43 E Market St, Rhinebeck, NY
Pizzeria Posto fires up thin-crust Neapolitan pies with a soft center and perfectly charred edges. The open kitchen lets you watch the dough fly, and the menu rotates with the seasons. It’s Rhinebeck charm, served one slice at a time.
15. Brooklyn Cider House
📍Location: 155 N Ohioville Rd, New Paltz, NY
Brooklyn Cider House brings the orchard-to-glass experience full circle with their wood-fired pizza. The crust is crisp and rustic, designed to pair with their funky, dry ciders. It’s casual, delicious, and always worth the detour.
Why not turn your pizza crawl into a weekend getaway? With cozy cabins, dreamy mountain views, and waterfront stays scattered across the region, it’s easy to hop from slice to slice. You might even end up skipping the restaurant table altogether, pizza tastes pretty great on a porch with a view.
